Four Hours Of Horror: How Market Day Became A Massacre Day In Taraba Community

 

The Taraba State Police Command said the death toll had risen to 58, including 15 people who drowned while fleeing in an overloaded canoe

For about four hours on Friday, gunmen reportedly rampaged through Binnari, a rural community in Taraba State’s Karim-Lamido Local Government Area, shooting at residents, looting shops and setting houses ablaze as terrified villagers fled for safety.

The attackers struck on the community’s weekly market day, when traders and buyers from surrounding settlements converge to exchange farm produce, food and other goods.

By the time the assailants withdrew, residents were searching nearby bushes and a river for missing relatives, while burnt houses, damaged shops and abandoned belongings testified to the scale of the destruction.

The attack on 23 October has left the community grappling with a mounting death toll, displacement and questions about how the gunmen could operate for hours in an area the state government had already designated a security concern.

The Taraba State Police Commandcsaid the death toll had risen to 58, including 15 people who drowned while fleeing in an overloaded canoe. The police spokesperson, Victor Mshelizah, said search operations led to the recovery of additional bodies from surrounding bushes and a river.

The figure represents a sharp increase from the 10 deaths initially confirmed by the police on Friday. Subsequent reports based on community accounts put the toll at 40 or 50 as more bodies were discovered.

The discrepancies in the casualty figures reflect the difficulties in establishing the full scale of the attack, with some residents still searching for missing relatives.

No group had claimed responsibility for the attack as of Sunday.

A market day turned deadly
For residents, the attack’s timing made the tragedy particularly devastating.

The weekly market is an important commercial centre for Binnari and neighbouring settlements, bringing together farmers, traders and other residents whose livelihoods depend on rural commerce.

According to accounts from community members, the attackers arrived in large numbers on motorcycles shortly after the congregational Muslim prayers and opened fire on residents. They reportedly looted shops, took cash, food supplies and motorcycles, and set houses and other property ablaze.

Abubakar Saifullahi, a community leader, told Agence France-Presse that the assailants carted away provisions and motorcycles abandoned by people fleeing the attack.

Mr Mshelizah said some residents died while attempting to escape across a river in an overloaded canoe, which capsized, resulting in additional deaths.

The recovery of bodies from the river and surrounding areas complicated efforts to establish the full extent of the casualties.

Residents question their protection
Beyond the loss of lives and property, the attack has renewed concerns about the ability of security agencies to protect isolated communities in Karim-Lamido.

A trader identified only as Adamu said the assailants operated for hours without resistance.

“We have no government in place,” he said, describing the duration of the attack and the destruction of goods during the market raid.

His account reflects residents’ frustration with inadequate protection and repeated attacks.

Yimita Sunday, a hunter and member of the Youth Security Volunteers Vanguard in Karim-Lamido, said poor roads, difficult terrain and weak telecommunications coverage hindered efforts to alert security agencies, reach victims and determine the extent of the destruction.

Eventually, local hunters and vigilantes reportedly pursued the attackers into the surrounding forests before security personnel arrived.

Ephraim Kwachi, an aide to the Karim-Lamido council chairperson, said the gunmen retreated towards settlements around the borders with Plateau and Bauchi states.

Local sources told PREMIUM TIMES that the attackers entered the community through a border settlement in Plateau State.

The police announced additional deployments following the incident, but a detailed public account of the security response during the attack was not immediately available.

Taraba’s overlapping security crises
The Binnari killings are part of a wider pattern of insecurity in Taraba, where communal clashes, farmer-herder conflicts, banditry, kidnapping and attacks on rural settlements have repeatedly threatened lives and livelihoods.

Unlike states where Boko Haram and the Islamic State West Africa Province have been the dominant security threats, Taraba’s insecurity has been shaped by a combination of localised conflicts, criminal activity and disputes over land, grazing routes and access to natural resources.

A security assessment by the European Union Agency for Asylum, drawing on data from the Armed Conflict Location and Event Data Project (ACLED), documented recurring violence across Taraba, including intercommunal clashes, land disputes involving Tiv and Jukun communities, farmer-herder conflicts, kidnappings and banditry.

The agency recorded 157 security incidents in Taraba between January 2024 and December 2025, resulting in 242 fatalities. It also cited an estimate of 62,564 internally displaced people in the state as of February 2025, largely in connection with communal clashes and insurgency.

These figures cover different forms of insecurity across the state and should not be interpreted as casualties or displacement caused by a single conflict.

Karim-Lamido has featured prominently in the violence. Its location near the boundaries with Plateau, Bauchi and Gombe states adds a cross-border dimension to security operations, particularly where armed groups can move through rural settlements and difficult terrain.

The European Union Agency for Asylum’s assessment recorded 26 security incidents in Karim-Lamido between January 2024 and August 2025, the highest number among Taraba’s local government areas during that period. Wukari recorded 24 incidents, while Takum recorded 23.

The figures illustrate the geographical spread of insecurity in the state, although the incidents differed in nature, severity and the actors involved.

A security concern before the massacre
The latest attack occurred despite Governor Agbu Kefas’ earlier intervention.

On 2 January 2026, Mr Kefas declared Karim-Lamido a special area of security concern through Executive Order No. 1 of 2026, citing recurring communal clashes, bandit-related attacks and violent farmer-herder conflicts.

The declaration aimed to strengthen efforts to restore peace, protect residents and create conditions for normal economic and social activities.

But violence has continued to threaten communities in the area.

In June, lawmakers called for urgent federal intervention following renewed clashes that reportedly killed at least five people and displaced residents.

The recurring violence has left communities confronting not only immediate threats to their lives but also the destruction of homes, farms and livestock, which are essential to their livelihoods.

For farmers and traders, insecurity can mean losing access to farmland, missing market days and abandoning businesses. Displacement can disrupt children’s education and access to healthcare, while repeated attacks make recovery increasingly difficult.

Binnari’s market day was therefore more than a commercial gathering. It was an important part of the economic and social life of a rural community now struggling to recover from a devastating assault.

Relief operation begins
Following the attack, the Taraba State Government ordered emergency assistance for affected residents and directed security agencies to restore calm and arrest those responsible.

The Taraba State Emergency Management Agency (TSEMA) deployed a team led by its executive secretary, Echuseh Audu, to distribute relief materials and assess the damage.

The first phase of the intervention included food and non-food items for affected households and displaced families. The agency also began assessing damage to homes, shops and livelihoods to determine the additional assistance required.

The government said the relief operation would be followed by further support based on the assessment.

Mr Kefas condemned the killings and directed security agencies to protect lives and property, restore normalcy and bring the perpetrators to justice.

The police also announced the deployment of additional personnel, including tactical units, mobile police officers and conventional police, alongside the Nigerian Army and other security agencies.

Residents were urged to remain calm, stay vigilant and provide credible information to security operatives.

Before the attack, the governor had also approved ₦1 billion for the Taraba State Bureau for Peace and Conflict Management to support peacebuilding, address the consequences of earlier crises and facilitate the safe return of displaced people in Karim-Lamido.

However, the latest killings have raised fresh questions about the effectiveness of existing security measures and whether peacebuilding commitments have translated into sustained protection for vulnerable communities.

The relief operation addresses immediate humanitarian needs, but it does not establish how the attackers reached Binnari, why they were able to sustain the assault or what measures will prevent another attack.

As of Sunday, the government and police had not publicly announced arrests linked to the killings or provided details of a new, long-term security plan specifically for Binnari.

Calls for investigation and accountability
Amnesty International Nigeria has called for an impartial investigation into the killings, justice for the victims and reparations for affected families.

The organisation’s reported casualty figures also highlighted the need for authorities to account for missing residents and establish the full scale of the attack.

For affected families, the immediate concerns include recovering and identifying bodies, arranging burials and securing support for survivors. Displaced residents also need shelter, food, healthcare and assistance to rebuild their homes and livelihoods.

But the attack raises broader questions for the state government and security agencies: whether early-warning systems are working in remote communities, whether security personnel can reach threatened settlements quickly, and whether intelligence is shared effectively across state boundaries.

Identifying and prosecuting those responsible would be an important step towards justice. Preventing further violence, however, will require sustained security operations and attention to the conflicts and criminal networks that continue to threaten rural communities.

Binnari’s weekly market may eventually reopen, and affected families may receive additional assistance. Rebuilding confidence will require more than delivering relief materials.

For residents who fled gunfire into bushes and a river, the central question is whether they can return home without fearing another attack.

Until authorities can demonstrate that vulnerable communities such as Binnari are adequately protected, the killings will remain a grim reminder of the gap between official security commitments and the safety residents experience on the ground.

SOURCE: PREMIUM TIMES